Rating: ⭐3.2/5
The Count of Monte Cristo (2024) is a French period adventure-drama film based on the renowned 1844 novel by Alexandre Dumas. Directed by Matthieu Delaporte and Alexandre de La Patellière, the film brings the story of Edmond Dantès, a man betrayed by his closest friends, to the screen with a fresh but faithful approach. Pierre Niney stars in the lead role, delivering a riveting performance as the iconic wronged man who rises from the ashes to seek revenge.
Premiering at the 77th Cannes Film Festival in May 2024, the film has already received widespread praise for its engaging storyline and breathtaking production design. With a production budget of €42.9 million, it became the most expensive French film of the year, and has grossed over $100 million globally.
Set in 1815, the film follows Edmond Dantès (Pierre Niney), a young, idealistic sailor who is wrongfully imprisoned after being betrayed by his closest confidants. Edmond’s downfall begins when he defies orders to rescue a shipwrecked woman, Angèle, who carries a letter from Napoleon, exiled in Elba. His actions spark the jealousy and rivalry of his ship's captain, Danglars, and his fiancée's cousin, Fernand, both of whom have their own ambitions for Edmond’s position and Mercédès’s (Anaïs Demoustier) love.
Edmond is arrested on the day of his wedding, accused of being a Bonapartist, a charge that is both false and politically motivated. The prosecutor, Gérard de Villefort (Laurent Lafitte), initially considers releasing Edmond, but when he learns of Angèle’s true identity and her connection to the exiled Napoleon, Edmond is imprisoned without trial. Edmond is sent to the Château d'If, a notorious island prison, where he meets the Abbé Faria (Pierfrancesco Favino), a fellow inmate who becomes his mentor. Over eight years, Faria educates Edmond and reveals the location of a vast fortune hidden on the island of Monte Cristo.
After Faria's death, Edmond escapes from prison by switching places with Faria's body and is thrown into the sea in a burial sack. He swims to freedom, beginning a journey of revenge and redemption. Upon returning to Marseille, Edmond finds that his father has passed away, and his fiancée Mercédès has married Fernand. Determined to settle the score with those who wronged him, Edmond adopts the persona of the Count of Monte Cristo and sets into motion a series of carefully crafted schemes to ruin his enemies.
Over time, Edmond uses his newfound wealth and influence to manipulate Fernand, Danglars (Patrick Mille), and Villefort (Laurent Lafitte), all of whom played roles in his betrayal. He begins by rescuing Fernand’s son, Albert, earning Fernand’s trust and gaining access to the inner circles of his former enemies. Through a series of well-calculated moves, Edmond orchestrates the downfall of his adversaries, exposing their darkest secrets and forcing them to confront the consequences of their actions.
Meanwhile, Edmond's relationship with Mercédès, now estranged, grows complicated. She begins to suspect that the Count of Monte Cristo is actually the man she once loved. Edmond also takes under his wing André (Julien de Saint Jean), an orphaned boy whom he later reveals to be Villefort’s illegitimate son, and uses him to further destabilize Villefort's life. Edmond’s quest for vengeance is methodical, but as the stakes rise, he begins to question the true cost of revenge and its impact on the people around him.
| Strengths |
|
|---|---|
| Weaknesses |
|
The performances are one of the standout elements of The Count of Monte Cristo. Pierre Niney is exceptional as Edmond Dantès, bringing a raw intensity to the role. His portrayal of Edmond’s transformation—from an innocent, hopeful man to a hardened avenger—is captivating. Niney’s nuanced performance allows the audience to empathize with Edmond, even as he carries out ruthless acts of vengeance.
The film also excels in its production design. From the sweeping Mediterranean vistas to the grim, fortress-like Château d'If, the sets and locations provide a rich backdrop to the action. The filmmakers use the grand scope of the setting to immerse viewers in the period, recreating the 19th-century world with attention to detail.
Another highlight is the film's ability to maintain the core themes of the original novel, particularly Edmond's moral struggle. His internal conflict as he seeks revenge on those who betrayed him is handled with emotional depth, making it clear that his journey is as much about self-discovery as it is about revenge.
While the film captures the essence of the novel, it falls short in terms of pacing and character development. The middle section, in particular, lags as Edmond’s revenge plans unfold with less intensity, making the narrative feel repetitive. Additionally, some secondary characters, such as Mercédès and Villefort, don’t get the same development as Edmond, and their motivations often feel less compelling.
The film’s focus on Edmond's revenge means that it doesn’t explore the broader philosophical themes of forgiveness and redemption as deeply as the novel does. Some viewers may find this oversimplification a missed opportunity to delve deeper into the moral dilemmas at play.
The Count of Monte Cristo (2024) is a thrilling and visually impressive adaptation of Alexandre Dumas' timeless novel. While it may not fully capture the novel's deeper themes or offer a completely fresh take on the story, it delivers a compelling narrative about betrayal, revenge, and redemption. Pierre Niney’s standout performance as Edmond Dantès anchors the film, and the rich cinematography brings the 19th-century world to life. Fans of the novel will appreciate its faithfulness to the source material, though the film might feel predictable to those already familiar with the story.
Download Now